
Air fryer or toaster oven. Why not both? The best combo units crisp fries with genuine air fry power while still handling everyday toast, bake, and broil duty, but the field ranges from full-size second ovens to compact baskets, and picking wrong means either overpaying for functions you skip or running out of room the first time you cook for a crowd. We looked at the Best Overall, the Best Budget Pick, the Best for Families & Batch Cooking, the Best for Small Kitchens, and the Best Non-Toxic Materials pick, and one countertop oven from a name you already trust in the kitchen kept coming out on top for all-around use. Here is how each one earned its spot, and who should buy which.
| Product | Air Fry Performance | Versatility | Capacity | Value | Build Quality | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() Best OverallBreville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro | 9.2 | 9.5 | 9.0 | 7.5 | 9.3 | See PriceAmazon |
![]() Best Budget PickGourmia 8Qt XL Digital Air Fryer | 8.0 | 5.5 | 7.0 | 9.5 | 7.0 | See PriceAmazon |
![]() Best for Families & Batch CookingNinja Foodi DT251 10-in-1 Smart XL | 7.5 | 8.8 | 9.3 | 8.0 | 6.8 | See PriceAmazon |
![]() Best for Small KitchensPhilips Essential XL Airfryer 6.2L | 8.3 | 6.0 | 6.5 | 8.0 | 8.0 | See PriceAmazon |
![]() Best Non-Toxic MaterialsOur Place Wonder Oven 13Qt | 7.8 | 7.5 | 6.8 | 7.8 | 8.5 | See PriceAmazon |

This is for someone who wants one countertop appliance to replace both a toaster oven and an air fryer, not just add another gadget to the counter. It fits buyers cooking real meals, not just snacks, who would regret a basket-only pick like the Gourmia the first time they need to roast a whole chicken.
This is the pick owners say they reach for more than their built-in oven, and once you use the Element iQ system's five independent quartz elements, it is easy to see why. Super convection cuts cooking time by up to 30 percent, and the 16 x 13.5 x 7 inch interior fits a full 9x13 pan or a 14-pound turkey, well beyond what a basket fryer or even the Philips's 6.2L capacity can handle. Thirteen cooking functions cover everything from dehydrating to slow cooking, so it genuinely replaces a second oven rather than just supplementing your air fryer drawer. Long-term owners consistently call it reliable, and the interior light and digital PID temperature control eliminate the cold spots that plague cheaper convection ovens.
Yes, if you want a single appliance that handles daily toasting, weekend roasts, and true air frying without compromise. If the price or footprint is the sticking point, consider the Ninja Foodi for less money, or the Gourmia if you only need the air fry function.

This is for the shopper who just wants crispy fries and wings without paying for toast, bake, or broil functions they will never use. It suits anyone who would regret spending $399.95 on the Breville for capabilities that sit idle in a one or two person kitchen.
At under $100, this is the pick that gets an enthusiastic thumbs up from budget-focused shoppers, including deal hunters who found the XL size selling for around $40 at Costco. The 8-quart basket is sized for real family portions, not a token snack drawer, and 12 one-touch presets take the guesswork out of cook times. It even dehydrates, so apple chips and jerky are possible without buying a separate appliance. It costs a quarter of what the Breville runs, and for straightforward air frying, that gap is hard to justify paying.
Yes, if air frying is genuinely the only function you need and price is the deciding factor. If you also want to replace your toaster or a second oven, look at the Breville instead.

This is for households feeding several people who need two cooking levels going at once, not just a bigger single basket. Families who would otherwise run the Gourmia in back-to-back batches get their weeknight time back here.
Owners of Ninja's combo ovens are some of the most loyal in the category, saying they use it more than their built-in oven for both speed and versatility. True Surround Convection cooks on two rack levels at once, doubling the capacity of a single-basket fryer, and a 90-second preheat gets weeknight dinners moving fast. It handles a 12-pound turkey with 360-degree roasting, and at $179 it undercuts the Breville by more than $200 while still covering 10 cooking functions. Air frying claims up to 75 percent less fat than deep frying, which matters for families cooking in volume.
Yes, if feeding a family in fewer batches matters more than top-tier air fry crisping. If consistent air fry results matter more than size, the Breville is the safer bet.

This is for someone with limited counter space who still wants enough capacity to skip a second batch. It fits buyers who would find the Breville's 16 x 13.5 x 7 inch interior too bulky for a small kitchen.
Multiple owners independently praised Philips air fryers in the same thread for being quiet and easy to clean, calling the larger sizes good enough to fully replace a standard oven. The patented starfish design circulates heat for even crisping with up to 90 percent less fat, and the 6.2L capacity cooks up to 4 dinner portions, plenty for most small households without the bulk of the Ninja Foodi's two-level system. Wi-Fi and Alexa control through the Philips HomeID app lets you monitor cook progress without hovering. The QuickClean basket's nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe parts keep cleanup genuinely fast.
Yes, if counter space and quiet operation top your list and you do not need toaster oven extras. For bigger batches, size up to the Ninja Foodi.

This is for buyers who specifically want to avoid PTFE and PFAS coated baskets and are willing to pay a bit more for a stainless steel interior. It suits anyone who would regret the coated nonstick basket in the Gourmia once they start reading ingredient and material labels.
Owners specifically praise this oven for being genuinely non-toxic: free of PFAS, PTFE, PFOA, lead, and cadmium, with a stainless steel interior paired with chromed steel, ceramic, and aluminum trays instead of a coated basket. Exclusive steam infusion technology uses just 1 to 2 teaspoons of water to refresh leftovers, a trick none of the other picks offer. It preheats 75 percent faster than a traditional oven and its 12L interior still fits a 4.5-pound chicken, more compact than the Breville but with a similar non-coated build philosophy. At $185, it undercuts the Breville by more than $200 while keeping the material story front and center.
Yes, if avoiding coated nonstick baskets is a real priority for you. If brand longevity matters more than the material story, the Breville has the longer proven track record.
The best combo ovens, like the Breville with its dual-speed super convection fan, match or beat basket fryers on crisping. Results vary more by the specific model's fan and heating element design than by whether it is a basket or a full oven.
Look for two-level cooking or an interior that fits a 9x13 pan or a whole chicken. The Ninja Foodi cooks on two racks at once, and the Breville fits a 14-pound turkey, both far outpacing a single basket.
Most nonstick baskets use PTFE coatings that are considered safe at normal cooking temperatures but that some buyers still prefer to avoid. If that is a concern, the Our Place Wonder Oven uses a stainless steel, ceramic, and aluminum interior instead.
A well-built combo oven can last years of near-daily use; long-term owners of the Breville report reliability well past the two-year warranty. Cheaper basket units can wear out sooner, though replacing one costs far less.
If you only ever plan to air fry, a basket unit like the Gourmia or the Philips costs less and takes up less counter space. If you want one appliance to also replace your toaster and a second oven, a combo like the Breville earns the higher price.
Owners are split: some use it daily and love the versatility, while others found a smaller Cuisinart model weaker than a dedicated air fryer, and the similarly named model lineup adds confusion when shopping.
See PriceAmazonDual heating elements and two-level cooking claim 40 percent faster cooking than a traditional oven, with a rotisserie function and dishwasher-safe accessories in a compact footprint.
See PriceAmazonOne owner gets excellent results by splitting the difference between the toaster oven's and air fryer's differing time and temperature guidance, once the settings are dialed in.
See PriceAmazon
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to leave one.